« Duelling languages - Peter K. Austin | Blog home | Black Swan redux - Peter K. Austin »

business learning training articles new learning business training opportunities finance learning training deposit money learning making training art loan learning training deposits make learning your training home good income learning outcome training issue medicine learning training drugs market learning money training trends self learning roof training repairing market learning training online secure skin learning training tools wedding learning training jewellery newspaper learning for training magazine geo learning training places business learning training design Car learning and training Jips production learning training business ladies learning cosmetics training sector sport learning and training fat burn vat learning insurance training price fitness learning training program furniture learning at training home which learning insurance training firms new learning devoloping training technology healthy learning training nutrition dress learning training up company learning training income insurance learning and training life dream learning training home create learning new training business individual learning loan training form cooking learning training ingredients which learning firms training is good choosing learning most training efficient business comment learning on training goods technology learning training business secret learning of training business company learning training redirects credits learning in training business guide learning for training business cheap learning insurance training tips selling learning training abroad protein learning training diets improve learning your training home security learning training importance
David Nash

Aspects of the Sydney Language are a perennial fascination. Last month recent events prompted me to look into the etymology of boomerang. In recent weeks the gripping SBS documentary First Australians first episode (available as a 227MB MPEG4) took us to the early days of Sydney.  And now I've noticed what I think is an unreported sound correspondence, as I've become more familiar with sources on the Sydney Language.

We can start with the correspondence that Lt William Dawes noted between dialects we can call coastal and inland, in the course of a 1791 expedition inland.  Dawes' notebook has a comparative table of six pairs of roots clearly showing a correspondence between intervocalic -nd- in inland Burubirangal with -n- in coastal Iyura. (The table is reproduced by Steele 2005:156, and Wilkins & Nash 2008:489-91). Dawes (c1790b) had also explicitly noticed an assimilation rule in the coastal dialect (Iyura), which can be restated thus: across a morpheme boundary potential nasal+d clusters do not surface but the d in this context is realised as n. Wilkins noticed that the observation could be generalised:

In the coastal dialect, there is a morphophonological rule which changed the initial stop consonant of a suffix to the homorganic nasal when that suffix was attached to a stem ending in a nasal. (Wilkins & Nash 2008:488)

Bilabial clusters

The rule changing the initial consonant of suffixes was also noted by Troy (1994) with respect to bilabials:

Analysis of the verbal morphology of the language provides further evidence for the transformation of b to m following n. (Troy 1994:27)

So I wondered about intervocalic bilabial nasal-stop clusters inside stems, not just ones that might arise from suffixation. The following table is an extract of all Sydney Language words written with an mb in Troy's (1994) 'reference spelling', together with each source form annotated with source abbreviation. The table columns are in two groups: words with mb in the left half, and any corresponding words with a corresponding m in the right half.

# gloss Troy 1994 source Troy 1994 source
1
sacred kingfisher djirramba jirramba (M) dyaramak dere-a-mak (HSB)
2
bat wirambi weeramby (C), werrimbi ‘flying fox’ (WR) [wirami]
weeream-my (An)
fox rat—large fox rat wiriyambi wee-ree-am-by (C) wiriyamin wee-ree-a-min (C)
3
wombat wumbat wom-bat (C), wombat (Fl), womback (Fl), wombat (R)  [wumat] womat (Fl)
4
brother-in-law djambi jambi (R)    
sister-in-law djambing jambiŋ (R)    
5
cattle—horned cattle gambaguluk kumbakuluk (R)    
6
stars gimbawali kimperwali (M), kimberwalli (R)    
7
shout gumba kumba (R)    
8
sprat gumbara kumbara (M)    
9
deaf gumbarubalung kumbarobalong (M)    
10
geebung (plant) mambara mambara (M)    
11
quail muwambi moumbi (M)    

Sources: (An) Anon. c1790, (C) Collins 1798, (Fl) Flinders 1814, (HSB) Hunter 1988, (M) Mathews 1903, (R) Rowley in Ridley, (WR) Russell 1914.

The records in the middle column, showing -mb-, are all from inland varieties as recorded by (M), (R) and (WR), whereas the examples with corresponding -m- in the right columns are from Sydney Cove and the coastal variety (allowing for Collins having recorded words from both varieties).  The blanks in the right columns show there is no recorded -m- equivalent of the -mb- words in those rows, and all those -mb- words are from the definitely inland sources (M) and (R).

Steele (2005:157) has also noted that "-mb is a non-permissible BB combination" (where BB is Biyal-Biyal, Steele's preferred name for the coastal variety), but did not state what happens to etymological mb.  Note that in row 2 Collins' 'fox rat' should probably be read as 'fox bat', a suggestion that has also been made by Steele (2005).

David Wilkins has noticed a possible instance of the correspondence -mb- ~ -m-, but between the Lake Macquarie Language (Awabakal) and Iyura. Lissarrague's (2006:113) reconstitution kampal 'brother (younger)', based on Kum-bul (Threlkeld 1834:87), Kumbȧl (Threlkeld 1892:54) and kambal (Horatio Hale), may well correspond with Dawes' (c1790b) gómůl 'A degree of relationship'. Troy (1994:39) reconstitutes this word as gumul but there is only one attestation and phonetically gamal is also possible.

All in all, it appears that intervocalic -mb- in inland varieties of the Sydney Language corresponds with intervocalic -m- in the coastal variety (Iyura) of the Sydney Language.

A Pama-Nyungan retention?

If the above evidence has established the -mb- ~ -m- correspondence, then we can see Dawes' (c1790b) unique record of kāma 'to dig' as a potential reflex of proto-Pama-Nyungan *ka:mpa- ‘cook in earth oven’ vtr (Alpher 2004:431).  This is known to descend as ‘cover, bury’ in some languages of Cape York Peninsula and central Queensland, but Alpher (2004) has no reflexes in southeast Australia.  Without another reflex of *ka:mpa- in the subgroup, there's a likelihood that kāma is a chance correspondence — so I would naturally like to hear of a potential southeast Australian reflex of *ka:mpa- (with suitable meaning). [Note: The other sound equivalences needed in this comparison are supported by pPN *kuna ‘excrement’ (Alpher 2004:439-40) descending as Sydney kuni (M), gonin (guni 'excrement' -in 'from') (Tench) 'excrement'.]

Velar clusters

Now, having covered alveolar and bilabial, what about other places of articulation, you ask.  Well, David Wilkins (p.c.) has made the generalisation that Iyura (the coastal variety) probably lacked any homorganic consonant clusters. On any potential correspondence between palatals -ñdj- and -ñ- there is a dearth of evidence; suffice to say there is no evidence of palatal nasal-stop clusters in Iyura.  For velars the data present a messy picture, given the ambiguity of early spellings with intervocalic 'ng'.  The scraps of data include the form of the 'dingo' word, and a couple of others which I consider first.

The early source Anon. (c1790) (Troy's (1994) source (c)), which can usually be taken to represent the coastal variety, has at least two words with a fairly definite indication of a nasal-stop cluster:

'banksia Banksia ericifolia' wadanggari wa-tang-gre (c)
'cabbage tree Livistona australis' daranggara ta-rang-ge-ra (c) (from Troy 1994)

These words would suggest that intervocalic ŋg is allowed in the coastal variety — but these could actually be representations of heterorganic ng, or could be inland words.  Furthermore, as David Wilkins has kindly pointed out to me, Dawes (c1790b) listed wadangal wȧtaŋál among 'names of flowers bearing honey …' (Troy 1994:61-2) which clearly has a simple nasal not a cluster, and may well be the coastal equivalent of this banksia word.

For completeness: there is just one possible set showing a related but different variation: the correspondence -ŋg- ~ -g- (not -ŋg- ~ -ŋ-):

'swamp wallaby, Wallabia bicolorbanggaray bag-ga-ray (c), bag-gar-ray (C), baggaray (P), ban-ga-ray (A), bag-ga-ree (W), guraya gorea (R) (from Troy 1994)

but again the one variant with nasal, ban-ga-ray, might be a representation of heterorganic ng, that is, the reference spelling perhaps should be bangaray not baŋgaray.

Dingo

The original phonetics of the word 'dingo' (the Australian dog) has long been somewhat of a puzzle; unfortunately it does not occur in the best source, Dawes' notebooks.  The source variation (based on Troy 1994) can be set out according to what the spelling implies about the medial consonant(s):

-ŋg- or -ng- or -ñg- indeterminate: -ŋg- or -ŋ-
or -ng- or -ñg-
-ŋ-
tein-go (C) dingo (T), tingo (A) (F) tung-o (An)
din-go (C) jungo (Pa) tung-oro 'dogs' (An)
Tun-go-Wo-re-gal† (An) jūnghō or dingo (R) jung-o (C)

† This entry is an interpolation in the manuscript; it includes wuragal wor-re-gal (C), waregal 'large dog' (A), and is inserted above Tung-o 'a dog'
Sources: (A) Collins, Phillip and Hunter (King 1968:270-274), (An) Anon. c1790, (C) Collins 1798, (F) Fowell (1988:93), (Pa) Paine (1983:41-42), (R) Rowley in Ridley, (T) Tench (1979:49[83]). Coastal: (F), (T), (A), (Pa) and usually (An); Inland (R); both: (C).

The simplest account of the variation in the above records is that there were two pronunciations diŋu (coastal) and diŋgu (inland), fitting the earlier discussion of correspondences implying parallel variation in homorganic nasal-stop clusters at the other places of articulation.  The possibility of a heterorganic cluster ng or ñg cannot be ruled out, but it is not able to account for the spellings implying simple ŋ (the right hand column above).  [Note: I propose the reconstituted forms diŋu and diŋgu just with respect to the medial consonant(s): the initial consonant may well be a laminal stop and the first vowel might be u, but these are matters for another discussion.]

As far as I know a corresponding form is found outside the Sydney region only to the north, in Awabakal, the Lake Macquarie Language, for which Threlkeld's 1834 An Australian Grammar lists

Tin-ku, a she dog. (p.10)
Ting-ko, A bitch (p.92)

Both these spellings represent a nasal-stop cluster, but according to Amanda Lissarrague's (2006) analysis it appears that from the available Awabakal data we cannot distinguish heterorganic nk or ñk from homorganic ŋk.

Here is what others have postulated as to the form of the origin of dingo.  The 1988 Australian National Dictionary (AND) [a. Dharuk diŋgu] and the 1991 Macquarie Dictionary (2nd ed.) [Dharuk dinggu] proposed a homorganic cluster. Then Dixon in Australian Aboriginal words in English proposed the possible heterorganic clusters:

[Dharuk, Sydney region din-gu or dayn-gu …] (1st edition, 1990 page 65)
[Dharuk, Sydney region probably din-gu (or possibly dayn-gu) …] (2nd edition, 2006 page 54)

and more recently has settled on just din-gu (Dixon 2008:134). Troy (1994:51) proposed dingu, repeated in her chapter in Macquarie Aboriginal Words (1994:69); this could mean heterorganic dingu or simple diŋu; it is not to be read as diŋgu otherwise her spelling would be 'dinggu'.

My current best proposal is this: (1) the First Fleeters encountered coastal diŋu in the first months of the colony and some did their best to represent the intervocalic nasal in what they wrote down; (2) a few years later the colonists encountered inland diŋgu; (3) English phonotactics and English spelling conventions favoured what happened to be the inland pronunciation, the variant with ŋg, and this became the universal English pronunciation.

I am grateful to David Wilkins for ongoing helpful discussion about the Sydney Language.

Sources

    Alpher, Barry. 2004. Proto-Pama-Nyungan etyma. Appendix 5.1, pp.387-570 on CD-ROM accompanying Australian languages: classification and the comparative method, ed. by C. Bowern and H. Koch. Amsterdam, John Benjamins.
    Anonymous. c1790.  Vocabulary of the language of N.S. Wales, in the neighbourhood of Sydney. (Native and English, but not alphabetical). Marsden 41645(c), SOAS Library.
    Collins, David. 1798. Appendix XII — Language, in An account of the English colony in New South Wales : with remarks on the dispositions, customs, manners &c. of the native inhabitants. London : Cadell and Davies. e-text
    Dawes, William. c1790b. Vocabulary of the language of N.S. Wales, in the neighbourhood of Sydney, Native and English, by -- Dawes. Marsden 41645(b), SOAS Library.
    Flinders, Matthew. 1814. A Voyage to Terra Australis. London: G. and W. Nicol. Facsimile reprint
    Fowell, Newton. 1988 [1788]. The Sirius letters. The complete letters of Newton Fowell, Midshipman and Lieutenant aboard the Sirius flagship of the First Fleet on its voyage to New South Wales, edited by Nance Irvine. Sydney: The Fairfax Library.
    Hunter, John. 1989. The Hunter sketchbook. General editor, John Calaby. Canberra: National Library of Australia.
    King, Philip Gidley. 1968 [1793]. Lieutenant King's journal, pp.196-298 in An historical journal of events at Sydney and at sea 1787-1792, by Captain John Hunter, Commander H.M.S Sirius; with further accounts by Governor Arthur Philip, Lieutenant P.G. King and Lieutenant H.L. Ball. New edition edited by John Bach. Sydney: Angus and Robertson.
    Lissarrague, Amanda. 2006. A salvage grammar and wordlist of the language from the Hunter River and Lake Macquarie. Nambucca Heads, NSW: Muurrbay Language and Culture Centre.
    Mathews, Robert H., 1901, ‘The Dharruk language and vocabulary’, [a section in] The Thurrawal Language. Journal of the Royal Society of NSW 35:155–160.
    Paine, Daniel. 1983. The journal of Daniel Paine 1794-1797, together with documents illustrating the beginnings of government boat-building and timber-gathering in New South Wales, 1795-1805, edited by R.J.B. Knight and Alan Frost. Sydney: Library of Australian History.
    Ridley, William, transmitting John Rowley. Language of the Aborigines of Georges River, Cowpasture and Appin. The Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 7 (1878), 258-62.
    Russell, William "Werriberrie". 1991 [1914]. My recollections. Camden, NSW: The Oaks Historical Society for the Wollondilly Heritage Centre.
    Steele, Jeremy Macdonald. 2005. The Aboriginal language of Sydney : a partial reconstruction of the indigenous language of Sydney based on the note books of William Dawes of 1790-91, informed by other records of the Sydney and surrounding languages to c.1905. Thesis (Master of Arts (Research), Division of Society, Culture, Media & Philosophy, Warawara - Department of Indigenous Studies, Macquarie University, Sydney. Available from Macquarie University ResearchOnline. With CD-ROM ‘Bayala Databases’.
    Tench, Watkin, L. F. Fitzhardinge, et al. 1979 [1961] [1793]. Sydney’s first four years : being a reprint of A narrative of the expedition to Botany Bay and A complete account of the settlement at Port Jackson. Sydney: Angus and Robertson, in association with the Royal Australian Historical Society. Electronic book, eBooks@Adelaide.
    Troy, Jakelin. 1994. The Sydney Language. Produced with the assistance of the Australian Dictionaries Project and the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies.
    Wilkins, David P. and David Nash. 2008. The European ‘discovery’ of a multilingual Australia: the linguistic and ethnographic successes of a failed expedition, pp.485–507, Chapter 18, in The history of research on Australian Aboriginal languages, edited by William McGregor. Pacific Linguistics 591

Comments

David Nash's findings on the Sydney language, and his mention of David Wilkins' observations, reminds me of the nasal-cluster dissimilation rule in Koko-Bera whereby in nasal-stop clusters in successive syllables the first one loses the stop. Hence kampvli 'to cook in earth oven', Past kamvnt. Sort of the opposite to what you find in (is it?) some Ngumpin, where the stop is lost. Anyway, it had occurred to me that something like this (losing either the stop or the nasal) could be a source for the complete simplification you find in YYoront & some Warluwaric or in Yolngu or in, apparently, coastal Sydney: the classic generativist rule-simplification, producing analogical regularization of paradigms.

Nice data on Sydney area. There seems to be a lot of this kind of alternation around NC and N eg mb and m. Barry mentions alternations motivated by following nasal clusters - what I called Nasal Cluster Dissimilation (later renamed Nasal Coda Dissimilation)in a 1988 article, later reprinted. Most of the emphasis whas on the form of NCD which deletes or denasalises a nasal following a nasal-oral cluster but the regressive form with deletion of the oral stop was also mentioned.

But these forms and others do not necessarily have that kind of environment.

For instance the 'sibling-in-law' term in the Sydney data jambi(ng) does not (as far as we know) have a jami- form even though though the apparent feminine form provides an NCD environment.

This root has apparent cognates in terms for mother's father, cross-cousin, spouse and sibling-in-law in many areas of Australia both in Pama-Nyungan and non-Pama-Nyungan. These kin types are commonly equated in Australian systems.

In various places across this range there is correspondence between a jampV- form and and a jamV- form in closely related languages.

A number of the NPN forms do have a nasal coda coupled with the m variant eg Kija thamany 'mother's father'. But in many there is no sign synchronically or in recent history of a following nasal coda.

So I am suggesting that perhaps this Sydney phenomenon is part of a larger NC-N alternation pattern in many areas. What this pattern is is rather mysterious to me. It could be connected to NCD but that is not the whole story.

FWIW the rule in Bardi is N(C)VNC > NVC (cf inyjibina 'he died' vs ingarrjimbina 'they died'.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Enter the code shown below before pressing post

The Authors

About the Blog

The Transient Building, symbolising the impermanence of language, houses both the Linguistics Department at Sydney University and PARADISEC, a digital archive for endangered Pacific languages and music.
More

FAQ

Papua New Guinea FAQs from Eva Lindstrom Papua New Guinea (New Ireland): Eva Lindstrom's tips for fieldworkers

Australian Languages Answers to some frequently asked questions about Australian languages

Papua Web Information network on Papua, Indonesia (formerly Irian Jaya)

Hibernating blogs

Indigenous Language SPEAK

Langguj gel Australian linguistics and fieldwork blog

Interesting Blogs

Omniglot Writing systems and languages of the world

LingFormant Linguistics news

Language hat Linguistics news and commentary

Jabal al-Lughat Linguistics news and commentary on a range of languages

Living languages Blog with news items and discussion of endangered languages

OzPapersOnline Notices of recent work on the Indigenous languages of Australia

That Munanga linguist Community linguist blog

Anggarrgoon Claire Bowern's linguistics and fieldwork blog

Savage Minds A group blog on Anthropology

Fully (sic)

Language on the Move Intercultural communication and multilingualism

Talking Alaska: Reflections on the native languages of Alaska

Culture matters: applying anthropology Australian anthropology blog: postgraduates and staff

Long Road ethnography and anthropology blog - including about Australia

matjjin-nehen Blog on Australian linguistics, fieldwork, politics and the environment.

Language Log Group blog on language and linguistics

Links

E-MELD The E-MELD School of Best Practices in Digital Language Documentation

Tema Modersmål Website in Swedish with links to sites on and in many languages

Hans Rausing Endangered Languages Project: Language Documentation: What is it? Information on equipment, formats, and archiving, and examples of documentation

Indigenous Peoples Issues & Resources a worldwide network of organizations, academics, activists, indigenous groups, and others representing indigenous and tribal peoples

Technorati Profile

Technology-enhanced language revitalization Include ILAT (Indigenous Languages and Technology) discussion list.

Endangered languages of Indigenous Peoples of Siberia

Koryak Net Information on the people of Kamchatka

Linguistic fieldwork preparation: a guide for field linguists syllabi, funding, technology, ethics, readings, bibliography

On-line resources for endangered languages

Papua New Guinea Language Resources Phonologies, grammars, dictionaries, literacy, language maps for many PNG languages

Resource network for linguistic diversity Networking practitioners working to record,retrieve & reintroduce endangered languages

Projects

ACLA child language acquisition in three Australian Aboriginal communities

DELAMAN The Digital Endangered Languages and Musics Archives Network

PARADISEC The Pacific And Regional Archive for Digital Sources in Endangered Cultures

Murriny-Patha Song Project Documenting the language and music of public songs and dances composed and performed by Murriny Patha-speaking people

PFED The Project for Free Electronic Dictionaries

DOBES Endangered language documentation and archiving, funded by the Volkswagen Foundation and sponsored by the Max Planck Institute, Nijmegen.

DELP Documenting endangered languages at the University of Sydney

Ethno EResearch Exploring methods and technology for streaming media and interlinear text