« Hints for speakers | Main | Science Blogging 2008—Part 2 »

On nomenclature

12 September, 2008

Following a brief snark in the office just now, I have a question for all y'all:

If viruses don't have a 'life'-cycle, what do they have?

Comments

First of all, I think the whole "Are viruses alive???" question is far less profound than most of the people who pose it think. It says nothing about life (which is what people seem to think it says), though it may be interesting in what it tells us about "life" the word. (The word dates to before the 12th century. Viruses were discovered in the 20th century. It is hardly surprising, or interesting, that a 12th century word doesn't cover all 20th century concepts.)

That said, I'm so tired of people asking, with that smug little glint in their eyes as they pose this profound philosophical conundrum their 3rd-grade science teacher presented to them, "Ah, but are viruses really alive?" that I call it a "replication cycle" instead, in an attempt to forestall them.

I would go with infection cycle or the replication cycle cited above.

I've even heard viral cycle

replicative cycle

Post a comment

Enter the code shown below before pressing post

About the Rat

Black Knight is interested in the interaction of science (as a day job and as a way of thinking) with his family, the wider community and literature. And tormenting students. Frequently polemical, sometimes serious, and hopefully always entertaining more

blackasknight@gmail.com

Recent Comments

  • nige said "replicative cycle"
  • Corey said "I've even heard viral cycle"
  • Paulo said "I would go with infection cycle or the replication"
  • iayork said "First of all, I think the whole "Are viruses alive"

Life

All your base are belong to us The BioLOG is back, bigger and bad to the bone

LabLit From the blurb: LabLit.com is dedicated to real laboratory culture and to the portrayal and perceptions of that culture – science, scientists and labs – in fiction, the media and across popular cultur

Mind the Gap Adventures in the London sci-lit-art scene...and occasionally beyond

Humans in Science Similar to 'Lab Rats', a very human look at the process of doing science and how daily life impacts our profession

Media

The Daily Grind Jonathan Sanderson, a TV producer interested in making 'popular science' shows

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 3.2